Blog

How do we protect our drawings and IP as a company when we share them with a manufacturer abroad?

For a company that is already in production, protection is not a signature on an NDA. It is what you share, when you share it, and what you can trace afterwards. On rationing the drawing package, tool ownership, and making unauthorised production visible.

Dolf Hendrikx

Co-founder and industrial design engineer ·

A company already in production does not protect its drawings with a single signature on a non-disclosure agreement. Protection comes from four things at once: an agreement that works in the country where it has to work, a package you release in stages, registrations in place before the files go out, and control over the tool and over what actually comes off it. An NDA states what is not allowed. The other three decide whether you notice, and whether you have anything to negotiate with when it happens anyway.

What does a manufacturer actually need to see, and what can you withhold?

He needs everything that drives the quality of his own work, and none of what drives your position in the market. That line is sharper than most companies assume.

| What he needs | What he does not need | | --- | --- | | Geometry per part, as STEP | The parametric history of your CAD model | | Material, grade and colour | Your purchase prices and margins | | Tolerances and inspection requirements | Your selling prices and sales channels | | The assembly, where he builds it | Your customer list and order book | | Volumes for the parts he makes | Your full bill of materials with every supplier | | Packaging, marking and documents | Firmware, source code and your test file |

The right-hand column is where most of the unintended leakage happens. A complete project folder with the bill of materials in it tells a manufacturer exactly where he can buy your other components and at what price. That is rarely the intention and almost always the result of convenience.

Pay attention to how you send, not only to what you send. One named contact on each side, files through an environment that logs who downloaded what, and no shared project folder that everyone can reach. It sounds like administration, but it is the only thing that later answers the question of who held which file. A drawing surfacing at a company you have never spoken to is a problem. A drawing you cannot trace back to a recipient is a bigger one, because then there is no conversation left to have.

Withholding is not free either. A manufacturer who has never seen the assembly cannot judge which tolerances actually matter, and you will get exactly what is drawn instead of what has to fit. So withhold what is commercial and share what is technically needed. If you genuinely do not want to hand over the geometry of one specific part, that tells you something about the role of that part, which is the subject of the next section.

How far can you split a drawing package?

Splitting works when your product has a natural seam in it, and it always costs something. The question is not whether it can be done, but whether the core of your product sits in one part or in the combination.

Four routes that hold up in practice:

  • Separate parts from assembly. The manufacturer makes the parts, assembly happens elsewhere or in house. He never sees the complete working product.
  • Place the critical part elsewhere. If your advantage sits in one mechanism, one geometry or one material combination, have that part made by another supplier, or closer to home. That is one of the trade-offs in our piece on reshoring.
  • Send production drawings, not design rationale. Your calculations, simulations, test reports and design decisions do not belong in the package. The manufacturer makes what is drawn; he does not need to know why it is drawn that way.
  • Revision control per recipient. Give every drawing a revision code and a recipient code in the title block, and keep a log of who received which revision and when. A drawing that surfaces later is then traceable to one recipient.

The honest downside: every split adds freight, extra purchasing lines, someone who has to hold tolerances across two suppliers, and an argument about who is responsible when the assembly does not fit. For a product whose value sits in the whole rather than in one part, splitting mostly buys cost. Work it through before you set it up, for example in a manufacturability review across the whole chain, where assembly and freight count as heavily as the parts themselves.

How do you establish who owns the tool?

In writing, with a number attached, and before the tool is built. In many cases the tool carries more of your IP than the drawings do: the cooling layout, the gate position, the shrinkage compensation and every correction that came out of the trials are all in that steel. Whoever holds the tool holds half the recipe.

Record this, per tool:

1. A unique tool number engraved in the steel, and an ownership plate with your company name on it. 2. An invoice that shows the tool as a purchase, not absorbed into a piece price. 3. A register of every tool, insert, spare part and gauge belonging to your product. 4. Photographs at handover and at every maintenance visit, including the condition of the cavities and the gate. 5. The agreed location, and that the tool only moves with your written approval. 6. A maintenance schedule with reporting, because a tool that is not maintained will not reach its rated life. 7. A return procedure with a deadline, including the 2D tool drawings, the hot runner specification and the spare parts.

Add a second manufacturer and you get a second set of tooling, so this list runs twice: numbers, ownership, location and return are recorded per tool, not per product.

The scenario where this hurts is always the same. A company has been running a product with the same manufacturer for years, decides to add a second supplier to spread capacity, and finds there are no tool drawings, the tool numbers were never recorded, and the tool appears on the invoice only as a one-off contribution. The conversations that follow are no longer about the product. They are about who is allowed to take what. At that moment the negotiating position turns out to be the reverse of what it looked like for years.

That last point is the one most often missing. A tool without drawings and without specifications is harder for another supplier to maintain and repair, which makes moving the tool without stopping production more expensive than it needs to be. In our process a signed mould property contract is therefore in place before production starts, not after.

What do you put on paper before the first drawing goes out?

An agreement that works in the country where it has to work, and the registrations you wanted anyway. What is enforceable differs per jurisdiction and is a question for a lawyer or patent attorney on the ground. What you do control as a company is what the document says and when you sign it.

Four practical points:

  • Cover more than confidentiality. For manufacturing in Asia it is common to add non-use, so the factory cannot make your design for its own account, and non-circumvention, so it cannot supply your customers directly. That combination is known as an NNN agreement.
  • Have it drafted locally. An agreement under the law of the manufacturer's country, in that country's language, with jurisdiction there, is more usable in practice than a translation of your own template. Make that call with local counsel, not with your manufacturer.
  • Sign before you send. Not at the first purchase order, but before the first file leaves. Set out which party receives which files, and what happens on termination to files, tools and remaining stock.
  • Register first, send second. In a number of jurisdictions, China among them, the first to file prevails over the first to create. In the EU an unregistered design right runs for three years from first disclosure in the EU; registration gives five years and is renewable up to a maximum of 25. China joined the Hague system for industrial designs on 5 May 2022, and the term of a Chinese design patent went from ten to fifteen years with the patent law amendment that took effect on 1 June 2021.

How do you spot production beyond your orders?

From the marking in the steel, not from a counter. This is where most advice on the subject goes wrong: a production tool almost never has a cycle counter in it. It is an extra component that has to be fitted and maintained, and nobody asks for one. If you do want one, agree it before the tool is built.

What you can have, and what it costs:

  • A cavity number and a date stamp in the steel. Standard work at the toolmaker and negligible in the price. Any unit that surfaces is traceable to a cavity and a production week.
  • Extra stamps or markings per batch. These let you follow a batch more finely, but they are extra work in the steel and therefore a cost. Weigh that against what you will actually do with it.
  • An annual tool inspection on site, with a photo report and the condition of the cavities. A tool that has run far more shots than your volume explains will show it at the cavities, the parting line and the gate.
  • Material that runs through you. If you buy the resin yourself, or have consumption reported per order, you have a second count alongside your order book.

On invented figures: you take 240,000 parts this year, produced in weeks 6 to 41. One surfaces at a company you have never spoken to, with cavity 2 and week 48 in the steel. You had no order running in week 48.

That is not proof; a remainder batch or a trial run can produce the same anomaly. It is a well-founded question, and that is the difference between a question and a suspicion. Without that marking you do not have the question at all. So agree the stamp layout at tool design stage, because adding a date stamp to existing steel means taking the tool out of production.

None of this makes copying impossible. What it does is reduce how much there is to copy, make deviations visible while you are still at the table, and make sure that when you move to a manufacturer in Europe or elsewhere in Asia, your tool, your documentation and your production leave with you instead of staying behind.

Production Heroes takes products from design to series production, from feasibility and cost price to sourcing and supply chain, and supplies moulds and tooling to manufacturers across Europe, from the Netherlands and its own presence in China.

Sources: the terms for the unregistered Community design (three years from first disclosure) and the registered Community design (five years, renewable up to a maximum of 25) follow from the Community Design Regulation (Regulation (EC) 6/2002). China's accession to the Hague system for industrial designs with effect from 5 May 2022 is published by WIPO and CNIPA (2022). The extension of the Chinese design patent term from ten to fifteen years follows from the amendment to the Chinese Patent Law that took effect on 1 June 2021. The example using cavity and week numbers rests on invented assumptions. This article describes what you record and measure in practice; it is not legal advice on what is enforceable in any particular country.

Frequently asked questions

Is an English-language NDA enough with a manufacturer abroad?
In practice an agreement drafted under the law of the manufacturer's country, in that country's language, with a court there, carries more weight than a translated version of your own NDA. Have the text drafted locally. This is not legal advice.
What is the difference between an NDA and an NNN agreement?
An NDA covers non-disclosure only. An NNN agreement adds non-use, so the factory cannot make your design for itself, and non-circumvention, so it cannot sell directly to your customers. For manufacturing in Asia, the second is what most companies work with.
Which files does a manufacturer not need?
Your full bill of materials with suppliers and purchase prices, your selling prices, your customer list, your firmware and your test file. Per part, he needs geometry, material, tolerances, surface finish and inspection requirements, plus the assembly where he builds it or has to judge it.
Who owns the tool when it sits on the manufacturer's floor?
Whoever has it in writing: a tool number, an invoice showing the tool as a purchase, photographs at handover and an agreed location. Without those papers the manufacturer is the one physically holding the tool, and you will not get it out quickly when you want to leave.
How do we spot production beyond our orders?
From the marking in the steel, not from a counter: a production tool almost never has a cycle counter in it. Have a cavity number and a date stamp engraved, and any unit that surfaces is traceable to a cavity and a production week. Extra batch markings are possible, but they cost money.
Should we register the design before sending drawings?
Registering before you send is the safer order, especially in first-to-file jurisdictions. In the EU an unregistered design right runs three years from first disclosure in the EU; registration runs five years and is renewable up to 25. China has been in the Hague design system since 5 May 2022.